Advantages and Disadvantages of Overhead Lines and Underground Cables

In electrical power systems, transmission and distribution of electricity are done either through overhead lines or underground cables.

Both methods have their own benefits and limitations, and every engineering or diploma student should clearly understand these differences for exams and practical work.

This post explains the advantages and disadvantages of overhead lines and underground cables, with simple points and a comparison table.

Comparison of overhead power lines and underground electrical cables with labeled components like insulation, conduit, and ground.

A visual comparison showing how overhead lines and underground cables are structured and installed for power distribution.

📌 What are Overhead Lines?

Overhead lines are conductors (wires) supported on poles or towers placed above the ground.

These lines are the most common and economical way to transmit and distribute electrical energy over long distances.

Key Points:

Easy to install and maintain.

Visible and accessible for repairs.

Common in rural and urban areas.

📌 Advantages of Overhead Lines

✅ 1️⃣ Low initial cost:

Overhead lines are cheaper to install than underground cables.

✅ 2️⃣ Easy to maintain:

Faults are easy to locate and repair because lines are visible.

✅ 3️⃣ Flexibility:

Changes and expansions are simple and less expensive.

✅ 4️⃣ Cooling:

Heat generated is easily dissipated into the air.

✅ 5️⃣ Long-distance transmission:

Ideal for carrying electricity over hundreds of kilometers.

📌 Disadvantages of Overhead Lines

❌ 1️⃣ Weather effects:

Exposed to storms, lightning, rain, and wind — which can cause faults.

❌ 2️⃣ Accidents:

Higher risk of electrical accidents if lines break or poles fall.

❌ 3️⃣ Land usage:

They require clear land corridors and can spoil the scenery.

❌ 4️⃣ Voltage drops:

Higher voltage drop due to long conductors exposed to environment.

❌ 5️⃣ Shorter lifespan:

More wear and tear due to external factors.

📌 What are Underground Cables?

Underground cables carry electric power below the ground.

They are mainly used in densely populated urban areas where overhead lines are not practical.

Key Points:

Installed under streets, pavements, or fields.

Well-insulated and protected from weather.

Require careful design for heat dissipation.

📌 Advantages of Underground Cables

✅ 1️⃣ Aesthetic:

No overhead wires — looks clean and neat.

✅ 2️⃣ Safety:

Less chance of accidents as cables are buried.

✅ 3️⃣ Weatherproof:

Protected from rain, storms, and wind damage.

✅ 4️⃣ Less transmission loss:

Better insulation reduces losses and faults.

✅ 5️⃣ Longer lifespan:

Longer life if properly laid and maintained.

📌 Disadvantages of Underground Cables

❌ 1️⃣ High initial cost:

Installation costs are higher than overhead lines.

❌ 2️⃣ Difficult to repair:

Locating faults takes time and special equipment.

❌ 3️⃣ Heat dissipation:

Heat produced is not easily released, so higher capacity cables are needed.

❌ 4️⃣ Expansion:

Extending or modifying an underground system is costly.

❌ 5️⃣ Limited capacity:

Underground cables are generally used for shorter distances.

📌 ✅ Comparison Table

Factor	Overhead Lines	Underground Cables
Initial Cost	Low	High
Maintenance	Easy & cheap	Difficult & costly
Fault Location	Easy	Hard
Safety	Less safe	More safe
Weather Impact	Exposed	Protected
Appearance	Visible, affects scenery	Hidden, neat
Expansion	Flexible	Not flexible
Cooling	Natural air cooling	Difficult
Typical Use	Long-distance transmission	Short-distance in urban areas

📌 Where Are They Used?

✅ Overhead Lines:

Commonly used for rural transmission, high voltage transmission from power stations, and in open areas.

✅ Underground Cables:

Used in cities, residential colonies, industrial areas, and places where aesthetics and safety are important.

📌 Conclusion

Both overhead lines and underground cables have their own advantages and disadvantages.

In practice, power engineers choose the method based on location, cost, safety, and practicality.

Overhead lines are best for long distances and low costs, while underground cables are better where safety and appearance matter more.

Knowing these pros and cons is very important for every diploma and engineering student.

📌 ✅ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1. Why are overhead lines cheaper than underground cables?

Because they need simple poles and wires, whereas underground cables need digging, insulation, and special protection.

More 2 Study